By Jade, board-certified health coach at ReviveX
Short answer: For next-day muscle soreness, the cold plunge has more research behind it. A Cochrane review found it reduced soreness compared with doing nothing. Whole-body cryotherapy may help, but there are too few good studies to say for sure. One important catch: if you're lifting weights to build muscle, don't plunge right after your workout. In one study, that slowed strength and muscle gains.
The cold plunge: real but modest relief
Cochrane is an independent group of researchers known for careful, no-spin reviews of medical evidence. Their review of cold-water immersion pooled 17 small trials with 366 people (Bleakley et al., Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2012). Here's what they found:
People who got in cold water (below 59°F / 15°C) after exercise reported less muscle soreness at 24, 48, 72 and 96 hours than people who just rested.
They also reported feeling less fatigued right afterward.
Contrast therapy (switching hot and cold) worked about as well as cold alone for soreness.
The authors rated the study quality as low and said better research is needed.
Bottom line: the cold plunge reliably takes the edge off soreness. It's not a miracle, but it's real.
Whole-body cryotherapy: promising, not proven
Cryotherapy means standing in a chamber of very cold, dry air for 2–4 minutes. Cochrane reviewed this too (Costello et al., Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2015). They found only 4 small trials with 64 people, mostly young men. Those trials leaned toward less soreness after cryotherapy, but the evidence was rated "very low" quality, and the authors concluded there wasn't enough evidence to say whether it works for soreness.
That doesn't mean cryo does nothing. Many of our members love how they feel afterward: quick, dry and done in minutes. It means the soreness research hasn't caught up yet. We'd rather tell you that than oversell it.
The catch: cold right after lifting can slow your gains
This one matters if you train at Results Fitness or anywhere else.
Researchers in Australia and Norway had 21 active men strength train twice a week for 12 weeks (Roberts et al., The Journal of Physiology, 2015). After every workout, half sat in cold water for 10 minutes and half did an easy bike cooldown instead.
The cooldown group gained more strength and more muscle.
Muscle biopsies showed the cold water blunted the repair signals that build new muscle.
The authors suggested rethinking cold water as a routine after strength training.
The likely reason: some of the inflammation after a hard workout is part of how muscle rebuilds. Cold calms it down, which feels great but may also mute the signal.
So when should you use cold?
Build strength or muscle (most Results members): On non-lifting days, or several hours after training, not straight after
Feel less sore before a game, race, golf round or busy week: Right after the hard effort is fine. Soreness relief is the goal.
Tournament weekend or back-to-back games: After each game, to feel fresher for the next one
Better sleep: Mornings or midday. Cold is alerting, so end evening visits with heat. See Does a sauna help you sleep better?
What this looks like at ReviveX
Results members on a training day: come in later or on your off day, and pair the plunge with infrared sauna or compression.
Weekend golfers, runners and high school athletes (14+): cold plunge or contrast after the event to bounce back faster.
Just plain sore and stiff? Contrast therapy (hot, then cold, then hot) gives you the soreness benefit and usually feels better than cold alone. Our contrast room pairs a traditional dry sauna with the cold plunge, so you can switch back and forth in one room.
Frequently asked questions
Is a cold plunge or cryotherapy better for sore muscles?
Cold plunge has more research behind it. A 2012 Cochrane review of 17 trials found it reduced soreness for up to 4 days compared with rest. A 2015 Cochrane review found too little evidence to say whether whole-body cryotherapy does.
Should I cold plunge after lifting weights?
Not right after, if your goal is strength or muscle. A 2015 study in The Journal of Physiology found 10 minutes of cold water after each workout led to smaller strength and muscle gains over 12 weeks. Use cold on off days or several hours later.
Is contrast therapy better than cold alone?
For soreness, they performed about the same in the Cochrane review. Many people find contrast more comfortable.
How cold is a cold plunge?
The studies in the Cochrane review used water below 59°F (15°C).
Sore, stiff, or training for something? Tell us what you're recovering from and we'll build your visit around it. Book your first visit · Call or text (203) 894-5289
Results Fitness members save 30% on ReviveX.
ReviveX is a recovery and longevity studio on Main Street in Ridgefield, CT. This article is for education and isn't medical advice.